By Editor-in-Chief, Timothy Gocklin, MBA, MSF
Indeed Ghost Jobs: Is Indeed a Waste of Time?
1. The Problem: Thousands of Applications, No Response
Across online forums and social media, job seekers are sharing disheartening stories.
A Reddit commentator described applying for 1,000 jobs on Indeed and receiving only two callbacks. They called LinkedIn similarly flooded and suggested many roles were already filled in-house.
Another Redditor on r/jobs asked, “Is Indeed dead?” Users replied that 95% of Indeed resume submissions are automatically rejected by bots. Many reported that applying directly to company websites provided the only callbacks they received.
Applicants are spending hours crafting resumes and cover letters yet receiving little or no follow-up. What is causing this?
2. What Exactly Are Ghost Jobs?
Ghost jobs, also called phantom or bogus listings, are advertisements for jobs that either do not exist or are already filled. These postings remain online for various reasons, including enhancing company reputation, gathering applicant data, or inflating job board statistics.
A 2024 Resume Builder survey found nearly 40% of companies had posted ghost jobs, with about 30% having at least one active bogus listing.
Greenhouse reports estimate that 18% to 22% of jobs advertised go unfilled.
An academic study using Glassdoor data estimated ghost jobs make up approximately 21% of all available positions.
A separate study revealed that in the consulting sector, ghost job ads increased 31% over two years.
A Wall Street Journal article estimated that 18% to 22% of 2024 job ads in various sectors were never intended to be filled. Business Insider further reported that the proportion of listings filled within six months fell from 91% in 2019 to below 50% by late 2024.
3. Why Companies Post Ghost Jobs
Ghost job listings may be more deliberate than nefarious.
- Talent pipelining: Companies gather resumes for future needs.
- Branding image boost: Firms post listings to signal growth or expansion.
- Employee morale: Open listings can make teams believe help is on the way.
- Compliance hiring: Some postings fulfill regulatory or internal requirements.
- SEO benefits: Fake ads can even boost web traffic.
Unfortunately, job seekers bear the brunt of this practice by investing time in applications for jobs that either do not exist or will never be filled.
4. Real Ghost Jobs vs. Delayed Hiring
Not all unfilled postings are deceitful. Business Insider clarifies the difference:
- Real ghost jobs: Never intended to be filled.
- Legitimate but delayed: Ads kept online during hiring freezes or extended vetting processes.
Either way, the result for candidates is the same—prolonged waiting or wasted effort.
5. The Cost to Job Seekers
Ghost jobs impose real costs:
- Energy depletion: Studies estimate it takes 2 to 10 minutes per application.
- Emotional fatigue: Repeated rejection creates the impression of a rigged system.
- Slowed progress: Chasing ghost listings delays the pursuit of real opportunities.
Reddit users often note the frustration of seeing the same ad reappear after being closed, reinforcing this perception.
6. Indeed vs. LinkedIn: Which Delivers?
Many job seekers have reported better results after switching from Indeed to LinkedIn.
On Reddit, one user explained that applying directly through company websites—often linked from LinkedIn—produced all three of their callbacks. Indeed provided none.
LinkedIn and Greenhouse have started verifying job postings to indicate real positions, bringing greater credibility.
In contrast, Indeed lacks a robust verification process and has been criticized for prioritizing ad revenue over authentic job listings.
7. Data: Job Placements and Callback Rates
Placement Fill Rates Over Time
- 2019: Approximately 91% of Russell 3000 postings were filled within six months.
- Late 2024: The rate fell below 50%.
Ghost Listing Prevalence
- 40% of companies posted ghost jobs in 2024.
- 30% of companies had ghost jobs active during surveys.
- 18% to 22% of ads across industries were never filled.
Callback Ratios
Forum data shows incredibly low callback rates—around 0.2% to 1% on Indeed—compared with higher rates when applying directly or through LinkedIn.
8. Why Applying Directly Works Better
- Bypassing middlemen: Direct applications avoid automated systems that reject non-keyword matches.
- Contact with real people: Applicants are more likely to reach actual hiring managers.
- Greater visibility: Internal and referral-based openings often have higher success rates.
Experts recommend verifying postings by calling the company, applying on corporate websites, and networking on LinkedIn.
2025’s Shocking CEO-to-Worker Pay Gap—and Why It Still Isn’t Closing, Read now on Terrene Globe
9. How to Spot and Avoid Ghost Jobs
Warning Signs
- Ads remain open for over 30 to 60 days.
- Job descriptions are vague or lack details.
- Positions are not listed on the company’s own website.
- Titles change slightly on reposts.
- No recent updates or timestamps on listings.
How to Avoid Them
- Verify postings through the company’s website or HR.
- Network with insiders to confirm openings.
- Track posting dates and ignore stale listings.
- Use vetted platforms like LinkedIn and Greenhouse.
10. Is Indeed Worth It Anymore?
Indeed was once a trusted resource for job seekers but now contains a high volume of ghost jobs. It still has some value, particularly for niche or remote positions, but users must be selective.
Best Practices
- Use Indeed as an alert tool rather than your primary job search method.
- Cross-check listings on company websites.
- Focus on applications with transparent companies.
11. Job Seeker Tips
| Strategy | Why It Works |
|---|---|
| Apply on company sites | Greater credibility, bypass ATS systems |
| Network on LinkedIn | Referrals increase success rates |
| Use verified job boards | LinkedIn and Greenhouse flag real jobs |
| Vet all listings | Avoid outdated or vague postings |
| Apply to fewer, better jobs | Customization increases your chances |
| Follow up by phone or email | Shows interest and uncovers real openings |
12. Conclusion
Indeed ghost jobs are distorting job seeker expectations. With nearly 1 in 5 postings fake or unfilled and fill rates halved since 2019, frustration is understandable.
Savvy applicants are not abandoning job boards entirely but are using them more strategically.
The future of job hunting lies in quality over quantity, due diligence over mass applications, and relationship-building over blind submissions.